畜牧与饲料科学 ›› 2024, Vol. 45 ›› Issue (2): 20-28.doi: 10.12160/j.issn.1672-5190.2024.02.003

• 动物营养与饲料科学 • 上一篇    下一篇

玉米秸秆与金针菇菌糠不同混合比例对发酵全混合日粮营养品质和霉菌毒素含量的影响

李小冬1,2, 于二汝2, 洪莉平1,3, 尚以顺1, 裴成江1, 罗近平1, 陈才俊1   

  1. 1.贵州省农业科学院/贵州省草业研究所,贵州 贵阳 550006;
    2.贵阳康养职业大学,贵州 贵阳 550081;
    3.贵州大学动物科学学院,贵州 贵阳 550025
  • 收稿日期:2023-12-19 出版日期:2024-03-30 发布日期:2024-05-06
  • 通讯作者: 于二汝(1985—),女,副研究员,博士,主要研究方向为特色饲料与遗传育种。
  • 作者简介:李小冬(1984—),男,研究员,博士,主要研究方向为反刍动物营养与生物技术。
  • 基金资助:
    贵州省科技支撑计划项目(黔科合支撑[2020]1Y080); 贵州省农业科学院高价值专利培育项目(黔农科院专利培计[2021]04); 贵州省科研机构创新能力建设项目(黔科合服企[2022]04)

Effects of Different Mixing Ratios of Corn Straw and Spent Flammulina velutipes Substrate on Nutritional Quality and Mycotoxin Content of Fermented Total Mixed Ration

LI Xiaodong1,2, YU Erru2, HONG Liping1,3, SHANG Yishun1, PEI Chengjiang1, LUO Jinping1, CHEN Caijun1   

  1. 1. Guizhou Academy of Agricultural Sciences/Guizhou Institute of Prataculture,Guiyang 550006,China;
    2. Guiyang Healthcare Vocational University,Guiyang 550081,China;
    3. College of Animal Science,Guizhou University,Guiyang 550025,China
  • Received:2023-12-19 Online:2024-03-30 Published:2024-05-06

摘要: [目的]研究以玉米秸秆和金针菇菌糠作为粗饲料加工调制肉牛发酵全混合日粮(fermented total mixed ration,FTMR)时二者的最佳配比,为菌糠等副产物高值化利用提供技术支撑。[方法]设置7个不同比例的粗饲料混合处理组,玉米秸秆与金针菇菌糠的比例分别为8∶2(T1组)、7∶3(T2组)、6∶4(T3组)、5∶5(T4组)、4∶6(T5组)、3∶7(T6组)、2∶8(T7组),再以精粗比为4∶6(鲜重)添加肉牛精料补充料,混合均匀后加工制成全混合日粮(total mixed ration,TMR);将不同处理组的TMR样品装入青贮袋,压实密封后抽真空,遮光保存于室内,自然发酵60 d制成FTMR;分别测定并比较TMR和FTMR的营养组分含量和霉菌毒素含量,同时,测定FTMR的发酵参数,确定最优配比。[结果]①随着玉米秸秆与金针菇菌糠配比降低,TMR的DM含量呈逐渐降低趋势,CP含量呈逐渐增加趋势,NDF和ADF含量总体呈逐渐增加趋势,EE含量呈波动性变化。②随着玉米秸秆与金针菇菌糠配比降低,FTMR的DM含量呈逐渐下降趋势,与发酵前相比,T4组的DM损失率最低;T3组和T4组FTMR的CP含量显著(P<0.05)高于其他组,与发酵前相比,T3组与T4组FTMR的CP含量增加;各组FTMR的EE含量差异不显著(P>0.05),与发酵前相比,T1组~T4组FTMR的EE含量下降,T5组~T7组增加;T1组~T5组FTMR的NDF含量显著(P<0.05)低于T6组和T7组,T3组NDF含量最低,与发酵前相比,T3组和T5组FTMR的NDF含量下降;T1组~T5组FTMR的ADF含量显著(P<0.05)低于T6组和T7组,与发酵前相比,T4组和T5组ADF含量下降。③各组FTMR样品均产生酸香味,发酵品质良好;T3组FTMR的pH值最低,显著(P<0.05)低于其余各组,T4组的pH值也较低;随着玉米秸秆与金针菇菌糠配比降低,FTMR的LA含量呈先增加后降低趋势,T4组含量最高,T3组次之,二者均显著(P<0.05)高于其余各组;随着玉米秸秆与金针菇菌糠配比降低,FTMR的AA含量呈先增加后降低趋势,T5组含量最高,T4组和T3组次之;各组FTMR样品均检测到微量的PA,组间差异不显著(P>0.05);T6组和T7组FTMR样品检测到微量的BA,其余各组均未检出;T3组FTMR的AN/TN比值最低,除T6组和T7组AN/TN比值超过10%外,其余各组均小于10%。各组TMR样品以及各组FTMR样品中AFB1、ZEN、OTA含量组间差异均不显著(P>0.05),参考《饲料卫生标准》(GB 13078—2017),发酵前后样品中霉菌毒素均未超过阈值。④主效应分析结果表明,发酵处理显著(P<0.05)降低了TMR的AFB1和ZEN含量,玉米秸秆和金针菇菌糠混合比例处理以及发酵和混合比例组合效应对发酵前后样品的AFB1和ZEN含量无显著(P>0.05)影响;发酵处理、玉米秸秆和金针菇菌糠混合比例处理、发酵和混合比例组合效应对发酵前后样品的OTA含量无显著(P>0.05)影响。[结论]综合营养组分和霉菌毒素含量以及发酵品质分析,采用玉米秸秆混合金针菇菌糠调制FTMR的方式能高效保存利用秸秆和菌糠等副产物,二者以6∶4(T3组)或5∶5(T4组)配比时效果较好。

关键词: 玉米秸秆, 金针菇菌糠, 发酵全混合日粮, 营养组分, 发酵品质, 霉菌毒素

Abstract: [Objective] The aims of the present study were to assess the optimal ratio of corn straw and spent Flammulina velutipes substrate as roughage in preparation of fermented total mixed ration (FTMR) for beef cattle, and to provide technical support for the high-value utilization of by-products such as mushroom bran. [Method] For the preparation of roughage, a total of 7 treatment groups with different mixing ratios of corn straw and spent Flammulina velutipes substrate were set up. Total mixed ration (TMR) were made from even mixing of corn straw and spent Flammulina velutipes substrate at the ratios of 8∶2 (T1 group), 7∶3 (T2 group), 6∶4 (T3 group), 5∶5 (T4 group), 4∶6 (T5 group), 3∶7 (T6 group) and 2∶8 (T7 group) with addition of beef cattle concentrate supplement at a concentrate-roughage ratio of 4∶6 (fresh weight). TMR samples from different treatment groups were placed into silage bags, and then compacted, sealed, vacuumized and stored in a dark room to naturally ferment for 60 days to prepare FTMR. The nutritional component and mycotoxin content of the prepared TMR and FTMR samples were measured and statistically compared. Furthermore, the fermentation parameters of FTMR were assessed to determine the optimal ratio of corn straw and spent Flammulina velutipes substrate. [Result]①As the ratios of corn straw to spent Flammulina velutipes substrate decreased, the DM content of TMR gradually reduced, the CP content gradually increased, the NDF and ADF contents generally elevated, and the EE content fluctuated. ②As the ratios of corn straw to spent Flammulina velutipes substrate decreased, the DM content of FTMR gradually reduced as well. Compared with the corresponding TMR, the FTMR in T4 group had the lowest DM loss rate. The CP content of FTMR in T3 and T4 groups were significantly (P<0.05) higher than that in the other groups. Compared with the corresponding TMR, the CP content of FTMR in T3 and T4 groups increased. No significant (P>0.05) differences in EE content of FTMR among different groups were observed. Compared with the corresponding TMR, the EE content of FTMR decreased in T1-T4 groups, but increased in T5-T7 groups. The NDF content of FTMR in T1-T5 groups were significantly (P<0.05) lower than that in T6 and T7 groups, with the lowest NDF content observed in T3 group. Compared with the corresponding TMR, the NDF content of FTMR in T3 and T5 groups decreased. The ADF content of FTMR in T1-T5 groups were significantly (P<0.05) lower than that in T6 and T7 groups. Compared with the corresponding TMR, the ADF content of FTMR in T4 and T5 groups decreased. ③The FTMR samples from all the treatment groups had acidic aroma and good fermentation quality. The pH value of FTMR in T3 group was the lowest, which was significantly (P<0.05) lower than that in the other groups. The pH value of FTMR in T4 group was lower as well. As the ratios of corn straw to spent Flammulina velutipes substrate decreased, the LA content of FTMR showed a trend of first increasing and then decreasing, with T4 group having the highest content, followed by T3 group, both of which were significantly (P<0.05) higher than the other groups. As the ratios of corn straw to spent Flammulina velutipes substrate decreased, the AA content of FTMR exhibited a trend of first increasing and then decreasing, with T5 group having the highest content, followed by T4 and T3 groups. Trace level of PA were detected in FTMR samples from all the treatment groups, and there were no significant differences (P>0.05) among the different groups. Trace level of BA were detected in FTMR in T6 and T7 groups, while the other groups were not detected. The AN/TN ratio of FTMR in T3 group was the lowest. FTMR in T6 and T7 groups had the AN/TN ratio exceeding 10%, while the other groups was less than 10%. The differences in AFB1, ZEN and OTA contents of TMR and FTMR samples among different groups were not significant (P>0.05). According to the Feed Hygiene Standard (GB 13078-2017), the mycotoxin content of the TMR and FTMR samples did not exceed the threshold. ④The main effects analysis showed that the fermentation treatment significantly (P<0.05) reduced the ABF1 and ZEN contents of TMR, while the treatment of the mixing ratios of corn straw and spent Flammulina velutipes substrate, as well as the combination effect of fermentation and mixing ratios, had no significant (P>0.05) effects on the ABF1 and ZEN contents of the TMR and FTMR samples. In addition, the fermentation treatment, the treatment of the mixing ratios of corn straw and spent Flammulina velutipes substrate, and the combination effect of fermentation and mixing ratios had no significant (P>0.05) effects on the OTA content of the TMR and FTMR samples. [Conclusion] Based on the comprehensive analysis on nutritional component, mycotoxin content and fermentation quality, the preparation of FTMR with corn straw and spent Flammulina velutipes substrate as roughage was an efficient way to preserve and utilize the by-products such as straw and mushroom bran. Corn straw and spent Flammulina velutipes substrate mixed at the ratios of 6∶4 (T3 group) or 5∶5 (T4 group) had the better performance.

Key words: corn straw, spent Flammulina velutipes substrate, fermented total mixed ration, nutritional component, fermentation quality, mycotoxin

中图分类号: